1 / 50
For SaleSingle Family Home
$3.0M
1621 Pineapple Avenue, Melbourne, FL 32935
Croton Road Area neighborhood
Subdivision: Eau Gallie Village Plat of
10
Bedrooms
8
Bathrooms
8,464
Sq Ft
1900
Year Built
$351 /sqft

About This Property

Description from listing agent

Don't miss this rare opportunity to own one of the most iconic and unique, waterfront properties in the Melbourne area. Once you pass through the gates and enter ''The Pineapple Estate'' you'll be become immersed in the natural splendor of it's Spanish Moss laden, hundred+ year old Oak trees, the historic architecture of the 5 different structures on site that that deliver over 8,400 liv sq ft , a heated pool, spectacular direct River views w/ a private dock, on approximately 200' of water frontage, and garage parking for up to 10 vehicles. The property has been both an expansive, private estate as well as enjoying a successful short term rental program. Everyone will appreciate the convenient location just minutes to the beach and all area amenities, including it being only a short stroll to all of the shopping, restaurant and night life options in the blossoming downtown Eau Gallie Arts District. Don't miss this once in a lifetime opportunity! Shown by appointment so call today !

Space Coast Context

🚀 Launch Viewing — Good Views

29.7 mi from SLC-40

29.7 miles from SLC-40 — visible on clear days, especially at night.

Aerospace Commute Guide
Northrop0.4 mi~1 min
L3Harris2.4 mi~5 min
Blue Origin23.9 mi~53 min
SpaceX24.9 mi~55 min
Lockheed25 mi~56 min
Boeing/KSC26.7 mi~1h
KSC27.2 mi~1h 1m

Estimates only — verify with Google Maps.

Flood Risk

Flood zone data not yet available for this listing. Check FEMA Flood Map

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer. Insurance estimates are ranges only — get a quote for accurate pricing.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
  • 12/17/24
    Listed
    $3.0M
    $351/sqft

Tracked by MaxxCity from the date each listing first appeared in our system — earlier history isn't available from the MLS feed.

Offer Intelligence

Price history and market context for this listing.

Price Reductions
No reductions
Listed price has not changed since hitting the market
How we match comps

Comps are pulled directly from the Space Coast MLS — sold sales only, closed within the last 180 days. We apply hyper-local matching criteria in this order:

  • Same property type, always (single family, condo, townhouse, etc.)
  • Single-story homes compared only to single-story (and multi to multi)
  • Exact bedroom count
  • Bathrooms within ±0.5
  • Garage spaces within ±1
  • Pool status must match
  • Waterfront status must match
  • HOA must match (HOA community vs. no HOA)
  • Price within ±5–20% of list price (tightest in early tiers)
  • Square footage within ±10–25% (tighter in early tiers)
  • Year built always within ±5–20 years (never dropped)

We search in tiers, expanding the radius only as needed — starting in the same subdivision within 1 mile, then 2 miles, then the same neighborhood within 3 miles, and the same zip code within 5 miles as a last resort. For luxury homes ($5M+), where nearby comps are scarce, we widen the search to 5–20 miles. Year built is always required so comps are from the same era of construction. The median is weighted toward nearer sales, and sales within the last 90 days count 2× to reflect current market conditions.

Median estimate is based on similar active listings and homes that have sold within the last 180 days in this area, as reported through Brevard MLS. This is not an appraisal or a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA). Before making an offer, work with a licensed real estate agent to obtain a CMA, or hire a certified real estate appraiser for an independent valuation.

Additional Details

Lot Size
1.37 acres (59,677 sqft)
Full Baths
7
Half Baths
1
Garage
10 car
Fireplaces
3
Waterfront
Indian River
Pool
Yes
Days on Market
560
MLS Area
323 - Eau Gallie

Schools

Elementary

Creel

Middle School

Johnson

High School

Eau Gallie

Financial & Listing Details

Listed
Dec 28, 2024
Parcel #
27-37-16-25-0000b.0-0014.00
$3.0M

Listing Agent (for property info)

D
David Settgast
One Sotheby's International
321-543-1187
Call Listing Agent

Estimated Monthly Payment

$18,800/mo
Principal & interest
$15,675
Property taxes
$2,975
Insurance
$150

Based on a 6.90% rate, 30-year loan, and $3.0M price — down payment shown: $595,000.

This is a quick estimate only — it does not include items like mortgage insurance, closing costs, or rate-lock terms. For an accurate payment based on your credit and finances, get pre-qualified with a certified bank or licensed mortgage brokerage.

MLS# 1032330

Interested in this property?

Equal Housing Opportunity

MLS# 1032330 · Listing Broker: One Sotheby's International · IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Listing information provided by Space Coast Association of REALTORS® and the Space Coast MLS. © 2026 Space Coast Association of REALTORS®. All rights reserved. · MaxxCity Realty LLC · Licensed in Florida.